Originally posted at Letters and Beans. That’s the one where I talk about books.
–
I fucked things up last week. I fucked things up in a spectacular, breathtaking manner, and in the ensuing retreat into my cave, where I could weep and lick my wounds in peace, I finally got around to reading my copy of Plan B by Jonathan Tropper.
It immediately reminded me of Joan Didion’s famous words: “We tell ourselves stories in order to live.”
Stories teach us how to live.
Stories can also serve as further confirmation of truths that I was only starting to guess at, truths that were brought home to me while I was in the process of fucking things up with someone I care deeply about. If my life was a Looney Tunes cartoon, then that particular moment was not unlike the anvil dropping on Wile E. Coyote’s head. I’ve been dwelling on the past. I’ve been viewing my life through the lens of the past, sifting through old hurts and picking at the scabbed over wounds. Every single thing I’ve said or written about lately is just another tired rehash of all of the ways in which life has fucked me over … or at least, all of the ways in which I think life has fucked me over.
Because it’s all about perception, isn’t it?
I’ve become the very thing that irritates the hell out of me: the girl who can’t stop banging on about past heartbreaks.
My first reaction to all of this was to stop writing completely. It’s an unnatural state of being for someone who is constantly thinking in words, but it’s the right thing to do for now. It’s time to stop thinking, to stop spending so much time in my own head, and just be in the moment.
But I will write about this gorgeous book. The protagonist, Ben, reminds me of myself: he, too, has a tendency to dwell on the past.
“In his debut, acclaimed bestselling author Jonathan Tropper captured the anxiety and humour of a group of friends as they near their thirtieth birthdays and have to come to terms with a milestone that they never thought would be like this. Ten years ago, they went into the world full of dreams for the future. But now, Ben’s getting a divorce, Lindsey’s unemployed, Alison and Chuck are stuck in ruts, and Jack is getting more publicity for his cocaine addiction than his Hollywood successes. Suddenly, turning thirty seems to be both more meaningful and less than they’d imagined it to be.”
When I first read that synopsis, I (correctly) predicted that this book would probably hit a little too close to home.
“[Thirty] It’s a weird age, isn’t it?” Don said…”Leads to a lot of annoying introspection.”
Preaching to the choir, brother. Okay, fine, I’m still a few years away from that momentous birthday, but I’m already caught up in the introspection that comes with realising that your life isn’t exactly where you thought it would be when you’re that close to thirty. The really funny thing, though, is that I’m really looking forward to turning thirty, if only because I’m utterly convinced that a) I’ll have all my shit sorted out by then, and b) I’ll be exactly where I want to be at that age: happily married, hopelessly in love (and loved hopelessly in turn), and about to start a family.
I may dwell on the past a fair bit, but I am also an optimist who believes things generally work themselves out. I’m a bundle of contradictions, yep.
But enough about me: let’s get back to the book. Plan B confirms my suspicion that Jonathan Tropper tends to work from a template, and that template was first established in this novel.
Let’s see:
Funny, self-deprecating Jewish protagonist with a mild inferiority complex? Check. – that would be Ben, the one who’s recently divorced and nursing unresolved feelings for his ex-girlfriend, Lindsey.
Overbearing but well-meaning mother, and emotionally absent but equally well-meaning father? Check – even if both make a single, very brief appearance in this novel. Mr. Tropper will go on to expand on the big dysfunctional family archetype in his later novels.
The perfect chance encounter between the protagonist and his romantic interest, one that is full of flirty banter and laughter? Check – Ben and Lindsey as college students, sitting out in the snow, and the “Peanut Story”.
Highly dramatic and near impossible to believe storyline? Check – Ben, Lindsey, Allison and Chuck kidnap Jack and whisk him away to Allison’s family’s vacation home in a small lakeside town in a desperate attempt to save him from himself.
The only thing missing here is the open-ended conclusion. Unlike in his other novels that I’ve read (How To Talk To A Widower, and my all-time favourite and Mr. Tropper’s best book yet, This Is Where I Leave You), things are neatly resolved in Plan B. Which is nice, really. It ends on a positive and hopeful, albeit bittersweet note, and you can’t help feeling positive and hopeful about your own life too as a result. There are so many lessons to be drawn from this book. The past is the past, and should really just stay there, because what really counts is the present. Nobody ever really feels like a proper adult. Stop over-thinking, because it leads to nothing good. Friendships evolve, and in some cases this means that it ends. Life is short; make the most of what little time you have.
Which brings us right back to the original lesson (or at least, the one that I’ve chosen to take from this book): the past is the past; stop dwelling on it. There are so many things to look forward to.
Look forward.
Oh, and expect a hell of a lot of angst and introspection in the lead up to the big three zero.
My favourite parts:
Thirty…shit.
Crows feet, jowls, love handles. I’ve started to see myself through the eyes of the teenagers I pass on the street, repeatedly shocked by the realisation that they see me as older. So many of the things I’ve eaten with impunity for years suddenly give me indigestion. Nothing feels new anymore. Everything I see just reminds me of something else. I know now that there are certain things I’ll never do in my life. A shirt I still think of as new turns out to actually be seven or eight years old. Seasons are quicker, holidays vaguely disturbing. Statistically speaking, I’ve used up more than one third of my life span, the healthiest third. And where are the tradeoffs? Where’s the authority? The wisdom? The confidence that was supposed to have come with adulthood? I’m only experienced enough to know that I’m as clueless as I ever was.
–
No one spoke for a while. The weather was cooperating with our moods, with pregnant, gray storm clouds that obliterated the sky. “It’s just that, you try so hard to get it right, you know?” I said. “To get your life to this point you’ve imagined in your head and you tell yourself that if I can just get to there, I’ll be happy. You all accuse me of living in the past, but the truth is I’m thirty years old and I’m still counting on the future to bail me out. And that’s a crock. You can spend years working toward something and get killed before you reach it, so what’s the point?”
“Because you probably won’t,” Lindsey snapped at me. “Chances are you’ll live until you’re ninety, which is a lot of time to spend in an unhappy life. Peter Miller may be dead, but look at how many people he affected before he died. He lived in the present. You’re worried that you might be wasting your time trying to achieve something when you might die tomorrow. You should be worried about getting your life together as quickly as possible so that if you did die young, at least you’d have lived. You’re young, you’re healthy…”
“Health,” I said, “is just the slowest possible rate at which one can die.”
Lindsey twisted around in her seat to glare at me. “Shut up, Ben,” she said. I did, for a minute.
–
And on that note, I’m off to get my life together. Properly, this time: with my eyes fixed firmly on the present, and the not-too-distant future.